While Christmas often evokes nostalgia, revisiting a familiar holiday film is a tradition worth keeping. However, there's an undeniable charm in discovering lesser-known cinematic treasures that radiate holiday cheer just as much as the beloved classics. While a slew of holiday films flood the market each year, only a handful achieve the coveted status of being timeless classics like A Christmas Story, Home Alone, and It's a Wonderful Life. Yet, there are many overlooked movies that deserve recognition for capturing the Christmas spirit with originality and sincerity. Though they may lack the nostalgia of enduring classics, these underrated gems provide a refreshing perspective on the holiday season.
Related: 10 Perfect Movies for You to Feel That Christmas Spirit
The 1940 film Remember the Night is a hidden gem, filled with tender performances and a heartwarming twist on a holiday redemption story. This overlooked classic tells the story of a lawyer who chooses compassion over judgment by bringing a shoplifter home for Christmas, resulting in a friendship that blooms into love despite the hardships of their harsh reality. An understatedly poignant script supports the leads' empathy and warmth through the use of timelessly hopeful tropes. Clever, earnest, and sweet, this golden-era drama merits greater appreciation for its skillful ability to touch the heart.
Roy Del Ruth's ensemble comedy revolves around Aloysius T. McKeever (Victor Moore), who spends each Christmas at the empty Fifth Avenue mansion of the second richest man (Charles Ruggles) while he's away. McKeever's generosity takes an unexpected turn when he invites ex-GI Jim Bullock (Don DeFore), his friends, and their families, including 18-year-old Trudy "Smith" (Gale Storm), to his home. Addressing the post-WWII housing crisis, Del Ruth's film offers a timeless exploration of how America addresses its veterans.
This heartwarming 1947 holiday classic, directed by Henry Koster, tells the tale of a stressed bishop, played by David Niven, who prays for guidance during a difficult church project. His prayers are answered in the form of an angel named Dudley, played by Cary Grant. However, as Dudley helps the bishop, he unexpectedly becomes a source of comfort for the bishop's wife, resulting in a funny and heartwarming journey about love, faith, and the true meaning of Christmas. The movie expertly combines fantasy, romance, and spiritual concepts.
White Christmas is a cinematic gem full of dance, song, and festive merriment that deserves greater acclaim. The script exudes warmth and wit, complemented by the delightful renditions of Irving Berlin's songs, skillfully performed by a cast of exceptional vocalists. The ensemble, featuring Bing Crosby, Danny Kaye, Rosemary Clooney, and Vera-Ellen, displays remarkable chemistry, weaving a kaleidoscope of humor that resonates throughout. From the exquisite costumes to the poignant finale, this Christmas masterpiece demands recognition.
In All I Want for Christmas, siblings play matchmakers for their divorced parents in a heartwarming tale. Despite its initial lukewarm response, this lovable family comedy, with ingenious plans by Ethan Embry and Thora Birch as well as a brilliant cast led by Lauren Bacall, has proven to be worthy of several holiday rewatches. A timeless holiday classic, this film embodies the true spirit of family and hope and radiates joy that penetrates beyond the surface.
Related: Savor These Delightful Short Films This Christmas Season
The late Angela Lansbury stars as Mrs. Claus in this made-for-TV holiday gem. Neglected by her husband during the pre-Christmas rush, Mrs. Claus (Dame Angela Lansbury) takes the reindeer and sleigh out for a drive, only to end up stranded in the multicultural neighborhood of Manhattan's Lower East Side of the early 1900s. After being taken in by a Jewish family, our heroine helps them resolve a variety of issues, including worker abuse and unrequited love. An Emmy-nominated song from Jerry Herman of "Hello, Dolly!" fame and Angela Lansbury's star power make Mrs. Santa Claus a must-see film.
Offering a delightful twist to the traditional Santa Claus tale, Fred Claus introduces us to the jolly old man's less-than-jolly older brother, Fred, who has been estranged since childhood. As Fred's romantic and legal troubles lead him to the North Pole, his skepticism clashes with Santa's festive spirit in a zany yet heartwarming fashion. Vince Vaughn's comedic brilliance shines through as Fred, complemented by Paul Giamatti's unique take on a lovable St. Nick. Amidst the laughter, these conflicting brothers rediscover the true meaning of Christmas, supported by a stellar cast that adds both humor and heart. With its unconventional perspective on Santa mythology, Fred Claus perfectly balances holiday hilarity with moments of emotional resonance, making it a must-see Christmas film.
Related: This Beautiful Story Unites All Generations at Christmas
Klaus received praise from both critics and audiences for its amazing animation, outstanding voice cast, and fascinating characters. Despite losing the Oscar for Best Animated Feature to Toy Story 4, it was a strong candidate. With each festive viewing, it appears destined to become a beloved Christmas classic for families.
The film establishes a new story around the origins of Santa Claus, set in the 1800s, and involves a mailman and an introverted craftsman. The brilliant, inventive writing does justice to the concept, and the voice talent adds warmth and charm to the film. Furthermore, the antique animation evokes nostalgia, while improved technology allows the traditional hand-drawn style to come through. If you're looking for a new holiday favorite, Klaus could be it.
